
Sugar cane Jaggery and Palm Jaggery ~ For this week’s Indian Kitchen
Jaggery and sugar are India’s gifts to the world!
I do not know how many of you know this but ancient Bharath (India) pioneered the sugar making technique. Harold McGee, the author of entertaining and educational cookbook “The Science and Lore of the Kitchen” describes in detail how thousands of years ago, India enamored the world with the taste and technique of sugar making. This is the first ’spice’ that was exported from India. These ancient traditions still continue and along with sugar, jaggery is also prominently used in Indian cooking.
There are two types of jaggery available in India as far as I know. One is from sugarcane and the second type is from Palmyra palm tree (toddy palm or taadi chettu) . Sugarcane juice (for cane jaggery) sap (for palm jaggery) from trees is boiled down hours and hours. And the concentrated liquid is poured into molds to dry. Depending on the mold used, you would see jaggery in different shapes- cylindrical blocks, smooth round balls and half spheres etc. Depending on the sweetness level and color, the jaggery is two types. Pale gold colored one - this is what’s available in most of the Indian grocery shops here in US. This is popular mainly because of my generation’s penchant for all things pale colored. Good, decent taste, I use it regularly in my cooking. But my parents and grand parents back in India prefer the dark colored jaggery. Aging or curing the freshly prepared jaggery for sometime will result in potently sweet, distinct flavored dark colored jaggery. For them, pale colored ones are inferior in taste. I agree that there is a significant difference between those two types. Because of this fact, often in our homes for marriages and special occasions, the dark colored jaggery is preferred to prepare sweetmeats.
When it comes to taste - jaggery has a distinct taste. English language, perhaps the most powerful tool and expression of current day culture, has millions of words but none of which are really good enough I think and there is no word in English that completely serves to describe the taste of Jaggery. If you have tasted one, cooked with one, smelled one, then you know the subtle sublime scrumptiousness Jaggery brings to a recipe. Otherwise, a translation attempt ‘tastes like molasses, brown sugar or maple syrup‘ is either an incomplete and false hint, for anyone who doesn’t know the taste of jaggery, or is simply annoyingly weak and unevocative.
Jaggery stores well. Once in 3 or 4 months, I buy a big block of jaggery from Indian stores. I break it using a knife and hammer. Place the knife in the middle of the block and lightly hit it with hammer. Jaggery breaks into pieces. Further gentle tapping with hammer results in small pieces and powdered jaggery. I keep what I need in a small container in kitchen cabinet and store the remaining pieces for later use in a Ziploc bag in the refrigerator. Just with 15 minutes work, I would be set for at least 3 months. I use jaggery in different traditional Indian preparations - to sweeten the curry sauces, for pappu chaaru and also to prepare sweets like payasam, kheer and cashew sweets etc. Back in home, in India, people often prepare sweets with jaggery. Particularly for naivedyam, jaggery sweets are preferred to sugar sweets. Our elders, they may not have degrees, but they do know where the ingredients come from and how they are made. They avoid sugar in naivedyam because after all sugar is processed by using dead animals bone meal.
One complaint I often hear about jaggery is presense of sand or dust particles in it. The reason for it is jaggery is still prepared in ancient way, in the fields. There will be harvesting of sugar cane going on one side and on the other end concentrating the sugar cane juice will be going on. Air carries some particles into this liquid. The farmers do filter the liquid before pouring into molds but one or two particles always find a way to join in. For some, these particles are reason why they avoid jaggery and prefer sugar. For me, I prefer sand particles to bonechar contamination anytime of the day. Atleast I know how to deal with jaggery impurities - melt and strain.
For the month of December, for Jihva - the online food blogging event, we the food bloggers are going to celebrate the goodness of Jaggery. All thanks to the new mom and the host of JFI, Kay, for her wonderful selection. Whether you are an already ordained admirer of jaggery by birth or it is your first time, join and (re)discover the subtle, sublime scrumptiousness of jaggery cooking, both in sweet and savory recipes.
It was very good information about Jaggery. My mom also uses Jaggery in most of the sweets because of its rich iron content.
Comment by sirisha — November 26, 2006 @ 8:53 pm
Hi Indira,
You have given a very good info about Jaggery. Wonderful description about this sweet ingredient used in many a item in our Indian cooking.
Truly,taste of Jaggery is distinct and irreplacable. As you said, it is considered a significant item in all the religious ceremonies and festive occassions.
You have provided an excellent detail on this ingredient. It was nice reading this post of yours.
Comment by Deepu — November 26, 2006 @ 9:05 pm
I use dark brown sugar instead of jaggery. It is a lot cleaner and made with the same ingredient and process as the jaggery. This is just my preference as I do not like the sand particles that you mentioned. Good information as usual. BTW/ anything bleached to a white color is evil - white sugar, bleached all purpose flour and white rice. Try using Turbinado sugar, whole wheat flour and brown rice.
Good luck with the Jihva event.
Comment by ash — November 26, 2006 @ 11:03 pm
Hi Indira,
I had posted about Jaggery on my blog too
, but long back
http://fitfulculinaria.blogspot.com/2006/11/jaggery.html#links
I had the opportunity to see the making of bellam (jaggery) while we lived in a village for a few months. The village’s main crop is sugar cane and every field had its own jaggery making unit. Infact what people know is only 3 stages, sugarcane juice, jaggery and sugar. But I was lucky enough to see the biproducts of it. While making bellam, at different stages they take out the stuff and call it some names and use it for making so many other condiments:)(Sorry I forgot all the names, hence the word stuff).
I particularly remember “panakam”…which is a thick dark syrup taken out at certain stage of making of bellam. It’s delicious and we used to eat idlis and attu with that. It’s not like the syrup we make at home with sugar or bellam. It’s different and very nice taste.
Your post brought back all the memories.
My personal favourite among bellams is the dark bellam (I don’t think its palm though, coz I had tasted palm jaggery and it tastes different and smoky)
I will try and participate in this JFI. It would be my first one
Comment by Tweety — November 27, 2006 @ 12:22 am
Indira,
Arun Shanbhag has written a very nice photo-essay on the jaggery making process. Here is a link:
http://arunsindia.blogspot.com/2005/11/sugarcane-fields-making-jaggery.html
Comment by Rainee — November 27, 2006 @ 1:38 am
What a wonderful post, you gave me some new information on Jaggery…and it is one of my fondest memories of eating the melted jaggery or ‘payo’ as it is called in Gujarati,whenever my mom made sweets…she would set aside for me!
Regards,Trupti
Comment by Trupti — November 27, 2006 @ 3:32 am
Well, dark brown sugar might be cleaner/easier but it certainly doesn’t have the same taste. To me, the taste isn’t even close, so I’m still faithful to these traditional sugars!
Indra, in Malaysia we have a kind of sugar called “gula melaka” — a black palm sugar, perhaps related to the dark jaggery? Anyway, it’s very similar to what you describe and we all, Indians, Chinese, Malays, all use it in our cooking. It is used especially for desserts, my favourite being a lovely dish of sago pearls (tapioca?) served with thick coconut milk and melted “gula melaka.” If you have a chance to find the gula melaka (Asian groceries often carry it), you must try this simple and satisfying dessert. I think you would love it!
Thanks again for your blog, by the way. It’s such an amazing resource.
Comment by Preeta — November 27, 2006 @ 3:54 am
Very good information,indeed,Indira.My father grew up in Bandar(Machilipatnam) and he always says that the dark coloured jaggery is purer.My ammamma also says that light coloured jaggery has lime mixed in it,which is why it is harder than the dark jaggery.I personally prefer the dark jaggery too,because of its taste and soft texture.
I love the taste of palm jaggery(taati bellam) as well.My mother’s collegue(in Orissa) once brought some for us, and since then,I am hooked on to it.I can’t seem to find it anywhere else though.
I will see what I cam come up with for the JFI..it will be my first JFI.I am so excited..
Comment by Vini K — November 27, 2006 @ 4:17 am
I forgot to add this Indira:My father says that eating jaggery along with roasted peanuts(palleelu) is very good for curing constipation esp in pregnant women.
Comment by Vini K — November 27, 2006 @ 4:22 am
Interesting post Indira…I used to use the hammer and knife method until i discovered the easy breezy method of using the microwave. Microwave large chunks of jaggery ina bowl for a minute or so, and they are soft enough to be rolled into small balls for one-recipe use. I do the same with asafoetida chunks.
Comment by nandita — November 27, 2006 @ 4:42 am
Very neat presentataion as always .
I logged on to my blog after almost a month and see your comment there. I am honoured Indira garu. TY so much.
-Ratnavalli
Comment by Ratnavalli — November 27, 2006 @ 6:02 am
Indira,
The main difference between jaggery and the white sugar is that jaggery is so full of iron along with I think a little magnesium. Thats why jaggery they say is good for your health while white sugar kills you. Even though it is sugar,they call it medicinal. In Naturopathy treatments,they use a lot of jaggery but never white sugar. They say white sugar is white poison.
I am not sure whether the jaggery we get in Kerala is from Palm, but it is very soft and we just scrape it using a knife. We get in the shape of balls. You get this jaggery in Kerala stores. Most Keralites I know never use the pale one.In fact, you never see the pale one in Kerala.
Looks like the brown colour one you have in your pic. Then there is another type of jaggery we called ‘karipetti’ which is a little hard, which they say is better than jaggery and is kind of medicinal.
No idea how these are all made. Need to ask someone.
Comment by InjiPennu — November 27, 2006 @ 8:27 am
Hey Indira
a useful tip is that microwave teh big chunk of jaggery - it will melt . u can store the fridge and keep using it
Comment by Revathi — November 27, 2006 @ 11:58 am
Hi Indira,
I came to know many things abt jaggery from your article.Thanks a lot for it..and enjoyed reading it too:-)…Good Job:-)
Comment by meena kandlakuti — November 27, 2006 @ 12:18 pm
hi indira,
wonderful post about the jaggery. inji, the sarkkara we get in kerala is not usually from palm, but from molasses. but the panamchakkara, or palm jaggery is there.
we do get pale sarkkara, especially in thrissur district. i like it better. that we get in that special shape called vellam. the other type, the ball variety is more common in southern districts. may be that is why you have seen that only.
karipetti is made from palm, with a lot of medicinal stuff like chukku, jeera etc added. i was addicted to karupetty tea at a time. it is a fine way to start a morning.
Comment by renu — November 27, 2006 @ 12:20 pm
How true your observation is Indira… my mom never makes payasam with sugar on festival days… always with jaggery (we call it mandai vellam… the dark one,sweet and no hint of lemon in it).
And also i remember that in Tirunelveli district (south of tamilnadu) people drink ‘karupatti coffee’. I don’t know how they make it except that karupatti is made from palm (as Renu mentions). this was a cheap alternative to coffee powder but healthy. They also make a delicious halwa… someone please correct me if i’m wrong!
Awaiting the recipes with jaggery..(thank u for choosing it for this month’s jihva, Kay!)
Latha
Comment by Latha — November 27, 2006 @ 1:30 pm
Very informative post Indira! The jaggery that is beloved in Bengal is date-palm jaggery also called ‘khejur-gur’ (I am not sure whether it is same as palm jaggery you show here). It has a distinct,amazingly aromatic taste and can be had just on its own, once it is liquified. This khejur-gur is used as flavouring multitude of bengali sweets during winter. Thanks for bringing back the memories.
Comment by Mystic — November 27, 2006 @ 2:39 pm
Very informative write up about Jaggary, Indira.My late grandfather used to grow sugarcane in our Mysore farm and make jaggary in square moulds to sell whole sale.My uncles are not interested in that now unfortunately.
I will post my Jihva tomorrow,something unusual as Kay asked for
Comment by Asha — November 28, 2006 @ 9:18 am
An informative post, which also revealed a few facts that I had no idea of, Indira. Thank you so much. I am a jaggery-lover anyway, but this ‘animal bone meal thing’ is gonna make me think twice more before I reach out for the sugar jar.
Also, I loved your critisism on the Indians’ growing love for ‘pale’ things. One of the things that I have noticed after coming back to India is the rise in fairness products. Wonder whether they use it to process jaggery too.
Comment by Vaishali — November 28, 2006 @ 9:48 am
Hi Indira
this is the first time i am visiting ur blog.Nice blog u have.This information is good.i know the preparation of jaggery as our relative has worked in an sugar factory.i went there when i was small but still now i can remember the smell of jaggery .it is full of iron and good for health.thanks for sharing.
Comment by swapna — November 28, 2006 @ 12:17 pm
Hi Indira, I really enjoyed reading this post about jaggery. I found it interesting to see the taste compared to brown sugar or maple syrup. In my opinion, jaggery might bear a *slight* resemblance to unrefined molasses, but it is nothing like maple syrup, and brown sugar is in another (inferior) league altogether. Since I started using jaggery I have happily stopped buying brown sugar. Jaggery most certainly has its own distinct flavor, and to my palate, is far more complex than the others mentioned. Now I will have to look for the darker palm jaggery, too.
Hope you had a nice holiday ~ Kittaya is looking gorgeous as always
Comment by Linda — November 29, 2006 @ 10:58 am
I was happy recently to find the dark (date palm) jaggery at a south indian store in the San Francisco Bay Area (Coconut Hill in Newark). I now have both kinds and use each according to the recipe at hand. I prefer the taste of the dark, but it doesn’t always suit every recipe as sometimes the taste is too prominent.
As usual, you have given us an informative and interesting posting to mull over - thanks!
Comment by Diane — November 29, 2006 @ 4:39 pm
A Sweet Treat
By Malkanthi Leitan
Feature Story from “Explore Sri Lanka”
(Article provided by the Sri Lanka Embassy)
Jaggery (popularly known as hakuru) has been a popular sweet as well as a much used sweetening agent in many a traditional dessert. IT is made from the Kaffery Plam (Caryota Urens), an attractive palm, also known as the Sago Palm, being outstanding for its much divided leaves and triangular leaflets. Known as Kitul in Sinhala and Kundal Panai in Tamil, the Jaggery Palm was chiefly cultivated in the Kandyan hills in ancient times for the sake of its sap, which is drawn, boiled down and crystallized into a type of brown sugar - jaggery.
Today, kitul jaffery is prepared in many areas of Sri Lanka, including Bandarawela, Badulla, Ingiriya, Kandy, Nuwara Eliya and other places. It is just one of the many products that can be derived from the Kitul or Jaggery Palm Tree. For example, toddy - a slightly intoxicating but nutritious drink - is obtained by tapping the tree when the tree is 15-20 years old and commences to flower. The sap, known as pani, is also used as a sweetener. From the interior of the stem, the sago-like starch can also be made into bread of boiled into gruel. Kitul fiber, made from the sheaths of the leaf stalks, is very strong and can be made into ropes, brushes, baskets, fishing lines and other articles. Kitul palm wood is much stronger and durable than that of other palms and can be used for many domestic purposes.
Ranjini, from Bandarawela, says that making jaggery is easy. She makes it by boiling kitul pani (the sap of the jaggery or kitul palm tree). “You have to boil it over a slow fire and stir until it becomes sticky and thick anddoes not drip from the spoon you are stirring it with,” says Ranjini. “It usually takes around 20 minutes to get the right consistency,” she says that the kitul pani must be the genuine thing and should not contain additives such as refined white sugar.
Next the mixture is poured into a coconut shell to harden. Ranjini recommends a well moistened coconut shell or a dry that has been lined with the leaf of a plantain tree. These methods will ensure that the mixture will not stick making it difficult to remove. Once the mixture has hardened, which doesn’t take very long, all you have to do is to tip over the coconut shell and the jaggery or hakuru will come out of its mold in its brown half-globe form.
Jaggery is best made from kitul pani. You can always tell if it is kitul jaggery because the product will be dark brown in color and soft. Jaggery can also be made from pani from the coconut palm tree - polpani. Unfortunately today, where pot jaggery is concerned, sugar is added and it doesn’t give you the real distinctive flavor of jaggery. Sometimes kitul jaggery can be adulerated with sugar, too. Always buy the darkest and softest jaggery, light and hard jaggery has probably been adulterated with sugar. However, genuine coconut or pol jaggery, without the addition of refined sugar, has a high nutrition content. For every 100 g of edible portion you get 1,638 mp of calcium and 62 mg phosphorous - bone, teeth and muscle builders.
During the Sinhala and Hindu New Year, jaggery or hakuru, is a popular ingredient in many a dish. Tradtional sweets such as bibikkan, kalu dodol and halapa taste good with jaggery.
Jihva for Jaggery: Palm Sugar or Panai Vellam
Thanks:Flickr
Palmyrah or Panai is very close to every Sri Lankan Tamil’s heart. We tend to use all parts of the tree. Northern Srilanka does not get much rainfall and Palmyrahs seem to flourish here. The scene above is how a typical village looks like from afar. I remember getting excited on seeing these trees when on long walks with my grandmother. Clusters of palmyrahs means human habitats and one can always request drinking water.
It’s been years since I left Sri Lanka. But, whenever I see a Palmyrah in India, I would be transported to Pungudutheevu, my home town. My family used to tease me a lot because I seem to remember more from the two years spent in Pungudutheevu compared to everything else - be it school lessons or even recent events.
Thanks:Flickr
As I said earlier, we tend to use all parts of the Palmyrah tree. The trunks are used as building materials. The Palmyrah has so many uses it’s practically impossible to list them all. To be truthful, I have even forgotten the different ways the Palmyrah was used back home. From what I remember the leaves were used mainly to make the sleeping mats. Narrow but lengthy coils of mats were also made. The mats were used when there are a lot of people in the house. These mats would be uncoiled and people would sit on them to be fed breakfast, lunch or dinner. Mats were also made to dry things on.
Containers of varying sizes would be made to store and transport goods both edible and not. One such container is called the ‘kadaham’ and it is so versatile. It could be used to transport paddy, rice, lentils or even cooked rice when there is a huge gathering to be fed. It could also be used to remove waste from the yard. We had 5-6 kadaham for different purposes. Puttu would be steamed in containers made just for this purpose. Well, being versatile, the same ‘puttu steamer’ would be used to drain water from washed rice and lentils. How long the ‘neethuppetti’ or ‘puttu steamer’ lasts depends on the usage. One household would have more than one and if more’s needed all one has to do is spend around 15 minutes to make a new one. Additional point in favour is that all these are bio-degradable and everything else is used as fuel.
Palmyrah tree has edible parts too. The mature fruit - ‘panam pazham’ could be roasted in fire and could be eaten just like that. Paniyaaram could be made from it and todate that remains my favourite snack. More on Panampazham and other countless uses of Panai or Palmyrah later. Another day, perhaps!
The reason for this post is ‘Panagatti’ ‘Karuppatti’, ‘Panai Vellam’ or Palm Sugar. The fruit when young and just forming would produce a sap that could use to produce ‘arrack’ - an alcohol. The same sap could be boiled to make Palm Sugar. The sap would be boiled and would be packaged in a container made from palmyrah leaves just for this.. You can see it in the photo above.
Palm Sugar - ‘Panangatti’ is used to make sweets. Unfortunately I dont know much about the recipes. [Time to call family, eh?;)] When young, we used to be given milk with a bit of palm sugar mixed in. It is our nightly ritual at home. I have recreated it here for Indira’s brainchild - Jihva For Ingredients. Kay of Towards a Better Tomorrow is hosting this month and the ingredient is Jaggery. With all my connection and passion to Palmyrah, how could I not participate. hmm?!
This is also my first time taking part in any online cooking event.
Hot milk infused with Palm Sugar
Recipe:
Milk: 1 cup
Palm Sugar: 1/2 tsp (or according to taste)
Boil milk. Add desired amount of Palm Sugar. Tastes very good on cold wintry nights.
Now to the non-regular recipe.
Caramelized apples with icecream
Recipe:
Apple: 1/2 apple
Palm Sugar: 1/2 tsp
Butter - 1/8 tsp
Peel, core and slice the apple. Add butter to the heated pan. Layer the pan with sliced apple. Cover and let it cook. Stir, once in a while. After about 2 minutes or once the apple is half cooked sprinkle the palm sugar. Cover and cook for a few more minutes.
On the serving dish, scoop out the icecreams and layer the caramelized apples.
In Tamil:
JFI:Jaggery - ?????????/??????????/??????????
for JFI-Jaggery hosted by Kay of ‘Towards A Better Tomorrow’
For more information on Palmyrah trees - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palmyrah
Kitul Pani: There’s another variety of Jaggery available in Sri Lanka. It’s the staple of Sinhala people
Brown is far superior than prestine white
Honey, jaggery (shakkar) Palm gur), molasses and unrefined brown
sugar are the preferred sweeteners than polished white sugar.Gur was
once considered as ‘poor peoples sugar’ and got rejected by people
who were becoming economically wealthy. Now there is a phenomenal
reverse trend where brown sugar costs more than double the costing
of refined sugar, after realisation by the riches about the
nutritive values of unrefined brown sugar.
Jaggery, Gur: The King of brown sugars,
Gur and Jaggery are made from unrefined palm sugar and unrefined
cane sugar, and available in the form of bars and sometimes in large
lumps. It is preferable to white sugar in many dishes. As it is
not sold in powder or granulated form it is hard to measure it like
the ordinary white sugar. As it is less sweet, one has to use one’s
own judgement and discretion when adjusting the quantities called
for in the recipes using white sugar.
Palm jaggery is made from the traditional palm sap of South India.
This is not made from date palm, this is the new entry that grows
widely in the arid regions of South India.
This palm jaggery is called karupatti in Tamil. It does have a
distinct taste. It does not come in large big balls or cubes like
sugarcane jaggery. The cubes are much smaller.
It is mostly used as a medicine in several siddha and ayrvedic
preparations, or candy by the kids. The palm sap is also made into
crystals, like sugar crystal candy. This palm crystal is called
panam kalkandu in Tamil. These crystals are not fine, they are
uneven and have light brown .
Both these products are made in small batches, usually a cottage
industry. So they have impurities, like fine sand or tiny pieces of
hay etc. But that doesn’t deter the people of South India from to
purify them and filter at home. The purified Gur syrup/crystalls
are then added to various food vareities.
The palm crystal is supposed to be good for dry cough. Also to
soothe the throat, we drink a tea made from the palm jaggery. This
jaggery is really dark in color, like blackstrap molasses.
The knowledge of traditional health comes from the people,
primarily, the women. They have the ability to heal both the body
and mind.
But now the people’s health traditions are on the verge of getting
lost due to modern medicine’s onslaught. In the Hippocratic system
the body caused the diseases and the body has the ability to heal
itself.
The diet plays a vital role in the process of healing and
recovering the healthy dynamic and enegetic state of mind and body.
Women play a role in preparation of Traditional foods for good
health on the Tamil New Years day.
Pongal or Paniyaram are prepared using hand pounded rice and Palm
Gur. A traditional cool and energetic feast is organized in which
pulses and cereals form part of the main menu. ‘’Two foods are
served traditionally on this day,” ‘a cooked mango salad and a neem
flower salad.” The raw mango, tempered with mustard seeds and red
chilies, is cooked in a sweet syrup from Gur or Jaggery. Its flavor -
- sweet and sour — signifies both the good and bad in life. The
bitter neem flower salad is prepared similarly. ‘’People eat the
neem salad first, before the meal,”. ‘’It means the bitterness of
life has been dealt with and we are now moving forward”.
The Neem Floor Rice, Neem flower Rasam are other specialities of the
New Year.
PONDICHERRY: The Chief Minister, N. Rangasamy on Thursday said
mothers should give a balanced diet to their children. “Only if they
eat food with lots of pulses, greens and nuts will they be able to
stay healthy, study well and contribute towards the development of
the country”, he told a one-day workshop for ICDS supervisors and
NGOs on “Micro nutrient deficiencies - a drain in Indian economy”.
Devi Mathews, Director, Department of Women and Child Welfare,
said “eating a balanced diet helps to prevent many diseases. Almonds
can be used in kheer. Also pongal with green gram dhal and kichadi
with vegetables are healthy food”.
“Lack of chromium in our diet makes us glucose impotent, which
causes diabetes? Most of us eat only to satiate our hunger and our
diet consists of rice, pulses and meat. We don’t bother about the
trace elements like magnesium, zinc, chromium, copper and fluorides.
These trace elements are very important and can be found in almonds,
pista and peanuts”, says Balasubramanian, Head of the Department of
Medicine, Government General Hospital, Pondicherry.
Dr. Balasubramanian said “low level of zinc leads to decrease in
sperm count in men and in carrying mothers it affects the formation
of foetus, genesis of embryo and growth of the child up to 5 years.
Trace elements are important for a lot of functions and they should
be added in salt instead of just iodine and iron”. Nuts consumed in
moderation and mixed with Gur/jaggery helps to reduce instances of
anaemia. “According to 2004 statistics, 63 per cent of Indian women
and 43 per cent of men are anaemic. Jaggery contains calcium and
iron and the nuts the trace elements. We are supposed to take 500 mg
of calcium everyday, which is 750 ml of wholesome milk (3 glasses
per day),” he said
Jaggery or “Gur” or whole sugar is a pure, wholesome, traditional,
unrefined, whole sugar.
It contains the natural goodness of minerals and vitamins inherently
present in sugarcane juice or Palm Juice & this crowns it as one of
the most wholesome and healthy sugars in the world.
Why is it healthy?
Jaggery or Gur, being a wholesome sugar, without doubt is rich in
the vitally important mineral salts: 2.8 grams per 100 grams, that
is to say 28 grams per kilogram, while only 300 milligrams per
kilogram is found in refined sugar.
Magnesium strengthens the nervous system & potassium is vital to
conserve the acid balance in the cells and combats acids and
acetone.
Jaggery is very rich in iron, which, a composite of hemoglobin
prevents anemia.
Sweet Switch
Jaggery satisfies your sweet tooth without the chemicals found in
processed sugar.
By Tamara Schryve
Americans consume an average of 152 pounds of sugar a year-an
increase of 30 pounds compared to two decades ago, according to the
U.S. Department of Agriculture.
Processing refined sugar from sugar cane, though, often includes the
use of harsh chemicals, such as sulfur dioxide, phosphoric acid, and
bleaching agents, that strip it of vitamins, minerals, and
phytonutrients, leaving the refined sugar as one what nutritionists
refer to as “empty calories.”
Yet not all sweeteners are nutritional duds. For those reluctant to
surrender their sweet tooth, there is a healthier alternative:
jaggery, a staple in many Eastern diets that is used to sweeten
foods like rice pudding, hot coconut milk, and vegetarian curries.
Jaggery comes from either the sap of sugar cane or palm trees, and
its flavor is described as an aromatic blend between brown sugar and
molasses with fermented or wine undertones. But what makes jaggery
superior to regular sugar is the way it’s made.
Because it is processed without the use of chemicals, jaggery
retains many vital vitamins and minerals, such as calcium,
phosphorus, magnesium, and potassium. In fact, jaggery has a mineral
content approximately 50 times greater than refined sugar and five
times more than brown sugar.
It sells in most East Indian markets in a spreadable form called
gur, or as a grainy, brown, coffee can-shaped chunk. Jaggery can be
used in practically any food or beverage where you might want to add
a few spoonfuls of sugar.
You can grate or cut jaggery into small pieces and add it to cereal
or coffee or tea; gur can be used on bread and other baked items.
Jaggery can also be chopped up and dissolved in water to form a
syrup to sweeten custards, rice, or even poured over ice cream.
You can substitute jaggery for granulated white sugar in many
recipes-you will need to use about one-and-a-half times the amount
of jaggery to achieve the equivalent level of sweetness.
Jaggery’s health benefits even go beyond the kitchen and even beyond
any one imaginable thoughts on various health benefits.
It has long been observed that people who work in highly toxic
surroundings and regularly consume jaggery, such as industrial
workers in dusty or smoky environments, have little or no bronchial
or lung discomfort. And a study in Environmental Health Perspectives
(1994: 211-214) reported that jaggery reduced the number of lesions
formed in rats’ lungs infiltrated with coal and silica dust.
Palm Gur and Jaggery
The true danger of white refined sugar seems to be that, due to its
overwhelming appeal to the human taste buds, everyone is appealed
to eat it in excess–often displacing other more nutritious foods
from the diet which is the genesis of development of coronary artery
disease, diabetes mellitus, obesity, and dental caries
Gur Jaggery’s health benefits
For centuries, jaggery has been used throughout India as a healthy
sweetener.To convert the plam neer or sap into gur, simple
evaporation or crude centrifugation is the only process. No
chemicals or bleaches are added. It is then simply poured into
moulds to form small cakes.
Jaggery, also known as gur, has a mineralcontent of approximately 60
times that of refined white sugar. Gur added sweet and food items
does not cause carving for food similar that caused by the
consumption of food items prepared with white sugar.
Remember, even jaggery must be used in moderation.
The important health foods not include food items prepared from hand
pounded rice, whole flour wheat atta, unpolished pulses & grams,
palm jaggery, but very frequently includes food prepared from Minor
millets such as Thinai (Setaria italica) and Kelvaragu (Eleusine
coracana), Kambu (Sorghum) and maize etc.
Thinai-Honey Offering to Thiruvalluvar
Thinai and Then play a crucial role in Kandapuranam epic.
Tiruvalluvar is believed to be king who ruled Valluvanadu and the
staple of their period is believed to be honey and ‘’thinai'’
(little millet) flour.
The ancestoral worship for Tiruvalluvar worship continues even now
by a specific tribal community in Kanyakumari district
('’Valluvankalpotrai'’ (Valluvan Hill) and the adjoining hill
called ‘’Valluvathi Potrai'’.
Thinai flour has more fibre content, protein content and vitamin B.
Very much help if regulary consumed for preventing diseases like
obesity, diabetes, arthiritis, high blood pressure and aneamia.
Unground Thinai can be boiled and taken like food similar to rice
preparation with vegetables. Thinai flour puttu and laddu other
delicious vareities.
Then - Thinai - Jaggery with some grated coconut is the best snacks
for kids
This is for the first time that the Nadar cuisine is brought out.
Due to the research, we will be able to preserve the recipes in a
docket form. Otherwise, it would have become extinct. People did not
know that such an exotic cuisine exists,” says Chef Khosla,
executive chef, Taj Krishna.
Offering insights into the fare, Chef Khumar says, “there are six
special masalas that go into the making of various dishes. The food
is rich  mutton is a delicacy that is tempered with mutton fat. For
desserts, rice flour fermented with toddy and sweetmeats made with
palm tree jaggery are popular.” So much for calories, but the
cuisine offers a plethora of flavours  from a chicken made with
garlic to bell pepper-flavoured meat vadas called Kari bondas.
Time for Paanakaram :
With summer fast approaching the Paanakaram which is the most served
to all public freely as customary drink during Summer festivals of
South Tamilnadu (Paankaram is the customary thirst quenching tamil
drink made with lemon juice, optionally a slight dash tarmarind paste
added to either Panangalkandu or cane jaggery and a pinch of cardamom
and/or dried ginger) or Sarbath (made from Nannari ver, Panaivellam
or Palm Jaggery and lemon concentrate) and chilled in earthen pots.
Many people do not prefer cold water from the refrigerator, for health
reason and they prefer the alternative use of traditional earthen
pots ( matka) which makes for water of just the right temperature to
slake one’s thirst.
Variants of Chukku malli kappi, chukku kappi or rather injii kaapi
prepared with Palm Jaggery are almost one and the same with slight
variations in the formulation is the best for intake in the evening
and in the night. Moreover regular habit of Chukku Malli Karupatti
coffee apart from increasing an individual’s health, it also
controls one’s desire for alcoholic drinks and help in move away
from habitual liquor addiction.
God’s own `chukkuvellam’
`Chukkuvellam,’ the boiled, medicated drinking water has become a
trademark of Kerala. Tourists have been fascinated by this herbal
concoction, often making this a habit. SUDHA NAMBUDIRI writes on the
goodness, carminative and digestive properties of this Ayurvedic
drink.
HAVING BEEN brought up by traditionally vegetarian and strictly
teetotaller parents in Tamil Nadu, Mr. Shanmugham was shocked to see
the yellow-coloured drink kept on every table during his lunch at a
popular vegetarian restaurant in Kochi. This was his first ever
visit to Kerala. Soon, the waiter placed a glass of same drink on
his table also. It took some time for the waiter to convince his
customer that the drink is not alcohol, but only boiled water,
medicated by herbs, to which most Keralites are habituated. Five
years hence, Mr. Shanmugham also regularly takes the boiled and
medicated water, the well-known `chukkuvellam.’
Often rousing the curiosity of tourists, `chukkuvellam’ has come to
stay as a trademark of God’s Own Country, for the last several
years, much the same way as the green tea of the Japanese.
The concept of `chukkuvellam’ finds its origins in Ayurveda. “There
is a saying in Kerala, `Chukkillatha kashayamilla’ (there is no
concotion without `chukku’ or dry ginger). In almost all Ayurveda
medicines, `chukku’ is a common ingredient because of its
carminative and digestive properties. According to Ayurveda,
indigestion in all levels of metabolism is the root cause of all
diseases. So a daily intake of such an ingredient is good enough to
keep sickness away,” says Dr. E. T. Neelakandhan Mooss of
Vaidyaratnam Oushadashala, Thaikkattussery.
Dr. K. Sreedharan Nair, retired Professor, Shoranur Ayurvedic
College and visiting physician, Keraleeya Ayurveda Samajam,
explains, “The `chukku’ has catalytic properties and hence it boosts
the medicinal value of other ingredients. After a sumptuous meal,
you find people serve `chukkuvellam,’ which helps digestion. In
Ayurveda, we often concentrate first on the stomach to see if the
ailment has anything to do with improper digestion. If we suspect
so, we advice the patient to starve for a couple of days and drink
only medicated water so as to cleanse the stomach off its undigested
food.”
Unlike common belief, `chukkuvellam’ does find its mention in the
Ayurveda texts. Explains Mooss, “In Rithucharya chapter of
Ashtangahridaya, while describing Vasantharithucharya, Sringiverambu
is advised for drinking. Sringiveram means ginger. Vasantham
(Spring) is the season of vitiation of `kapha dosha.’ Hence, food
and drinks, which alleviate `kapha’ are mentioned here,” elaborates
Mr. Mooss.
It is mentioned as `Anupanam’ or to be taken along with any
Ayurvedic medicine in the various texts, says Dr. M. Sunil Kumar,
Physician, Kottakkal Arya Vaidya Sala, Kochi. “For example, milk,
`jeera’ (cumin) or `malli’ (coriander) water are often prescribed as
such. `Karingali’ (a herb) is good for diabetics and `malli’ mashed
and put in boiled water overnight is good for morning sickness and
nausea in pregnant women,” he explains.
`Chukkuvellam’ is a colloquial name associated with medicated
drinking water. Prepared from a range of herbal constituents, it
comes in different colours, some of them being very attractive. The
original `chukkuvellam,’ which is made by boiling water with
`chukku’ has a turbid appearance and is slightly hot (chilli hot).
Most other types of `chukkuvellams’ are clear water, with
characteristic mild flavours. `Jeera’ gives a golden yellow colour,
the herb `pathimukham’ gives an attractive pink colour, and
`karingali’ gives a brownish colour.
For more than a decade or so, the hotel industry in the State has
been serving boiled water always, more so during the rainy season to
prevent water-borne diseases. Accordingly, hotels first serve boiled
water flavoured with some kind of `chukkuvellam’ powder available in
the market. Hotel Dwaraka, for example, has been serving
`chukkuvellam’ for the last decade or so. “Earlier, we used to serve
water boiled with coriander seeds. In the rainy season, most people
prefer medicated or boiled water. We don’t serve plain boiled water
as most people may not like its taste,” says Jayaprakash, manager of
the hotel. However, non-Keralites, especially the North Indians
prefer cold water and ask for it. While, foreign tourists prefer
mineral water and mostly demand certified brands. “Since they are
travelling they don’t like to change their drinking water as this
could upset their throat,” Mr. Jayaprakash adds. Manmadhan, manager
of the Indian Coffee House, subscribes to this view: “When people
ask for cold water or mineral water, we first explain to them that
this is boiled and medicated water and it is being served under
government instructions. But we have to serve what the customer
asks. Most North Indians prefer cold, mineral or plain water. But
the first thing on the table is medicated water only. For the last
eight years we have been serving water boiled with `pathimukham’.”
However, not all types of medicated water suit everybody. It depends
on the body constitution, seasonal variations and place of
residence. Explaining in detail, Mr. Mooss says that generally the
purpose of `chukkuvellam’ type of processed water is to increase
appetite, digest foods, clear abdominal discomforts etc. Hence herbs
with opposite qualities should not be consumed. For example, in
vitiation of `kapha’ and `vatha’ diseases, `chukku’ is good.
`Jeeraka’ alleviates kapha and `vatha doshas,’ but vitiates `pitha
dosha.’ `Pathimukham’ alleviates `kapha and pitha doshas.’” If one
is selecting drinking water on the basis of Ayurvedic science, a lot
of things have to be taken into consideration, he adds. Every
Vaidyan’s advice is that medicated water should be taken fresh, not
more than a day old. Dr. Sreedharan Nair emphasises this should not
even be stored overnight. Agrees Dr. Sunil Kumar, “The very meaning
of medicated water is that it has to be boiled for at least five
minutes, which most people seem to ignore. `Tulasi’ or pepper water
is good for cold and throat infections. `Panakam’ water has
ingredients like `ramachcham,’ `iriveli’ and sandalwood, which give
a cooling effect to the body in summer.”
All that is available in the market as `chukkuvellam’ powder may not
be good or made according to the instructions given in the Ayurvedic
texts, as far as the combinations of the ingredients are concerned.
It is said that some even add artificial colour. There seem to have
been instances of hospitals being unable to take X-ray pictures
because of the coating of these colours inside the body in some
patients.
`Chukku’ magic
DR. NEELAKANDHAN MOOSS of Vaidyratnam Oushadashala, Thaikkattussery,
explains some of the characteristics of `chukku’ (dried ginger),
which is used in almost all medicinal preparations especially in
decoctions. In Ayurveda, fresh ginger is known as `ardraka’ and
dried ginger is known as `suntee.’ In a lot of contexts we can see
`chukku’ as one of the ingredients along with other ingredients.
Some examples are :
a) Decoction of `mahabala’ root and `chukku’ checks malarial fever
with rigor and burning sensation in two or three days (Ref:
Bhavaprakasam)
b) Decoction of `chukku,’ added with honey, alleviates loss of
appetite, dyspepsia and cough (Ref: Bhavaprakasam)
c) One should take water processed with `vacha,’ `athivisha,’
`mustha,’ `parpata,’ `hribera’ and `chukku’ for improving appetite
and digestion (Ref: Charakam)
d) In case of toxicity, indigestion, piles and constipation one
should use regularly `chukku,’ `pippali,’ `harithaki’ or `dadima’
(Ref: Vrinda Madhavam).
e) Decoction of `chukku’ stimulates digestive fire quickly and there
is no need of other drugs for this purpose (Ref: Vrinda Madhavam).
f) Water processed with `kantakari,’ `chukku’ or `dhanyaka’ should
be given as post meal drink. It acts as carminative and laxative
(Ref: Charakam).
g) Taking a decoction of `chukku’ and `eranda’ root added with
`hingu’ and `souvarchala’ gives relief from pain instantaneously.
h) Hot decoction of `chukku’ promotes digestion, alleviates cough,
asthma, colic and heart diseases.
i) Boiled and cooled water processed with `bala’ or `prisniparni’ or
`kautakari’ combined with `chukku’ should be drunk in all cases of
alcoholism (Ref: Charakam).
Sugar as bad by another name
Kavita Mukhi
Last month I was in Delhi checking out some of the newer retail
outlets where my line of earth-friendly products will soon be
available. Because the manager was taking me to all his retail
points in Gurgaon, an extension of Delhi I was visiting for the
first time, I was being politically correct by making a purchase in
each store.
After having bought some products I needed, I stopped to look at
mints, sweets, licorice, chewing gum etc, strategically placed
at `impulse’ purchase points, to see which were the healthiest ones
I could pick up. The sales staff eagerly assured me that they were
all `sugar-free’. Taking a closer look I discovered that they were
indeed free of plain simple sugar. But they were replete with `white
poison’ i.e processed sugar and substitutes which are widely
believed to be harmless.
Of course they aren’t, though they may be marginally better than
pure white sugar. The same is true of a whole range
of `healthy’, `natural’, `diet-food’, `fat-free’, `low-calorie’ food
ingredients. I had to look very hard to find a non sugar-free
lozenge, the good old-fashioned one. My grandparents had the good
fortune of living with jaggery or gur, sans bleach or colour. My
parents have had to live with white sugar, bereft of the goodness of
gur. I am living with all kinds of chemicals infiltrating my air,
water and food.
Worse, they seep into the earth. It’s somewhat akin to nature’s
revenge for trying to be one up on her. Genetically modified,
hybrid, irradiated and pesticides-heavy foods, all contribute toward
making us more sick than we already are with the consumption of
refined or empty foods which fill the belly but do nothing to supply
nutrition to body cells, which is the very purpose of eating. The
gastronomical satisfaction of such food is its only virtue.
Therefore the true connoisseur or gourmet is a person who is able to
taste and appreciate wholesome food as nature intended. If you have
tasted genuinely organic fare, you’ll know what I’m talking about.
Because of my long and close connection with pure and safe food, an
involvement which began with my desire to feed my family right, I
have carefully studied the role of sugar in our lives. It’s sad to
learn that there’s a political angle even to something as simple as
a citizen wanting a natural sweetener. I have been advocating the
virtues of non-chemical, non-bleached and non-coloured jaggery for
over a decade and have prompted start-ups which produce traditional
gur shakkar (golden sugar) from chemicals-free, earth-friendly
sugarcane which  its health benefits apart  is easier to spoon
into your beverage than jaggery.
I have also been involved with the production and marketing of palm
jaggery from Goa (coconut palm) and Kerala (fan palm). They not only
infuse the body with instant energy but with beneficial minerals as
well. A close runner-up is khandsari (raw sugar) which although
nutritionally not on a par with gur is more beneficial than white
sugar. It is free of chemicals that make up white sugar, including
the animal bone used to process it. In effect it is `vegetarian
sugar’. Moreover unlike white sugar, it contains some nutrients.
To date nobody has produced raw sugar from chemicals-free, earth-
friendly sugarcane. So you can imagine my joy when I met a group of
people interested in doing so. But when we began discussing pricing
I realised that such superior sugar will cost the consumer more than
processed white sugar. And unfortunately price-sensitive Indian
consumers tend to be unwilling to pay more for healthy products.
So how come refined white sugar is so cheap? The main reason is that
it’s subsidised. Which is also why a few years ago the powerful
sugar lobby tried very hard to push through a ban on the factory
production of jaggery. Can you imagine this? Putting a ban on a
culinary tradition stretching back thousands of years? The headline
of an article in the Financial Express (October 12) explains the
situation well: “UP govt losing Rs.500 crore each year on 24 sick
sugar mills.” So we pay a low price for a pack of sugar but
eventually it is we who end up contributing by way of subsidies to
sugar mills. Not to mention paying by way of ill health.
According to reports Aspartame, an artificial sweetener, accounts
for approximately 70 percent of all complaints to the FDA. It is
said to be implicated in many health problems including blindness,
headaches and convulsions. Sold under dozens of brand names such as
NutraSweet and Equal, aspartame reportedly breaks down within 20
minutes at room temperature into several primary toxic and dangerous
ingredients. If this is correct you can imagine what happens to
crates of diet colas, sugar-free gums, sugar-free medication, all
sugar-free sweets in our tropical climate.
For many years I have been strongly advocating the importance of
reading `contents’ on labels, because most people merely read the
name of the product and get duped into purchasing something value-
less. There are many new products out there claiming to be low-
calorie, diet food, sugar-free, healthy, low-fat, etc. If you read
the fine print you will realise how the new substitutes are often
worse than the old offenders.
It boggles the mind to think of the future of children raised on
additives, not to mention foods grown with chemical fertilisers and
pesticides. Not enough research has been done on the ramifications
of continuous ingestion of such foods in the long term. The solution
of the modern world of course, will be more vaccines to cope with
newer diseases. When that multiplies the problem, we will wonder
what went wrong. But who will give back the years lost in emotional
despair of the young people who constitute the majority of India’s
population?
(Karuppatti, Panangalkandu, Koondhapanaikalkandu, ChilluKarupatti
etc) Palmgur, palm Jaggery Palm sugar, and Palm candy are the direct
products obtained from processing of Palm juice (Neera).
Palmgur is obtained by evaporation of juice (Neera) to a semi-sold
stage. Palm sugar and Palm candy are obtained in crystal form
prepared out of Palm syrup at the appropriate stage of
concentration and adopting suitable crystallization techniques.
These products are having valuable nutrients.
ChilluKarupatti prepared from original PalmNeera along with
DryGinger is one of the best traditional health candy product
alternative to various sweets made of refined sugar in our southern
state which is consumed as a supplementary with several traditional
snack foods.
Comment by tnv-ab — January 3, 2007 @ 6:53 am
Hi,
Gur is really benifitial.
Can someone plese tell me something more about commercial manufacturing processes / factories or some references. We are setting up a modern high capacity plant of gur.vivek.nirmal@hotmail.com
Comment by vivek — February 3, 2007 @ 8:23 pm
Hi,
I reside in San Jose,CA.
Can u please tell me where du get these Neem Flowers
Comment by Usha — March 5, 2007 @ 2:01 pm
hello,
I reside in Sandpoint, ID (North Idaho) Can you please tell me where or how (preferably online) I can purchase Jaggery?
Thanks!
Emily
Indira replies:
Hi Emily, A lot of my friends who live in places like Idaho and Montana etc, where there aren’t many Indian shops, usually purchase from “I Shop Indian”, an online shop. Here is the link to Jaggery from their shop. If you make a purchase, do let me know about your experience with jaggery. Thanks.
Comment by emily — March 8, 2007 @ 7:35 pm
I stay in Satara, Maharashtra- India.
I want to regularly purchase ‘tadgul’ i.e. jaggery made from neera( palm tree), as it is learnt that the tadgul is verymuch bebfitial as diet suppliment specially for bones.
Please let me know where I can get it.
Thanks
Comment by A P Harsule — March 10, 2007 @ 12:20 am
hi,
I reside in Bangalore, India. I wanted to purchase blackstrap molasses to have it in my diet everyday. Can someone pls tell me where can i purchase it in India preferrably in Andhra Pradesh.
Comment by Sudhistna — March 22, 2007 @ 3:36 am
I deperately want to know the BENGALI word for
BLACKSTRAP MOLASSES.
Please do help me.
Comment by sujata — September 4, 2007 @ 6:26 am
In Tamilnadu, various types of Palm jaggery (Palm Candy, Palm Gur etc) are sold through Sarvodhaya shops (Khadi Gramodyog shops) run by government to promote village industries. They are good tasty and beneficial. There are Palm gurs exported from South Tamilnadu from places like Udangudi, Sattankulam and neary areas
Comment by Raja — September 14, 2007 @ 11:39 pm
Is blackstrap molasses the same as palm jaggery or, at least, does palm jaggery (the dark variety) have the same nutritive benefits as blackstrap molasses. I noticed here that several commentators have asked similar questions. If blackstrap molasses is a byproduct of jaggery then where can one purchase it. I live in Mumbai and have found your blog by doing a search for jaggery.
Comment by Jennifer — November 26, 2007 @ 10:40 pm
hi, wonderful ,ur way of telling in a simple way is very simple, keep it up , after 60 years i came to know that
why sugar is not used in “NAIVADYAM’ thank u very much
dr manyam, maldives
Comment by dr manyam — December 3, 2007 @ 11:33 pm
is there a container were jagerry will come out in a crushed form because we have two break with hammer
Comment by prachi — January 2, 2008 @ 9:08 am
Every day I have naval pain sometimes not much
there are times severe pain depends what I eat.
At first my doctor told I have Colon cancer,
after test I found out that I have Inflamation
like a thumb size wound in my naval area.
Please can you advise me what I should take or hebal medicine to overcome this pain, please if you can Email to me whenever you get a chance,
JudeM@rogers.com Can you help? Love Jude
Comment by jude Mascarenhas — March 2, 2008 @ 4:33 pm
Jude, you could try giving up milk, sugar (use jaggery instead) and non-veg for some time till the wound heals. If that doesn’t help, you’d better see a doctor.
Comment by Jennifer — March 22, 2008 @ 5:41 am
Hello,
My husband is very anti-sugar but loves my baking. We have a 1.5 yr old daughter and he does not want her to have any sugar. He brought home some Jaggery from the local Indian shop, thinking it was date sugar and asked me to google it. We were pleased to learn all of the health benefits of Jaggery and I now use it in all my baking instead of sugar (I carve some off and chop it fine and use less then the required amount of sugar in my recipes). It is delicious, especially in the banana bread I made yesterday. Thanks for your information!
Ann
Comment by Ann — April 1, 2008 @ 12:56 pm
Answer to What is blackstrap molasses
Link below
http://www.earthclinic.com/Remedies/molasses.html
Comment by Manish — April 3, 2008 @ 8:46 am
Just saw this website. Great site. Thanks
Comment by TT — April 14, 2008 @ 12:35 pm
So, blackstrap molasses means karuppathi the Jaggery and it can cure grey hair?
Comment by Anu, Malaysia — January 28, 2009 @ 10:48 pm
iam using chukku kapi regularly its avilable in instant form in market named as ” Rajam Sukku Kapi “. really fine & good.
Comment by murali — June 2, 2009 @ 5:39 am
Interesting site with contributions from persons originating from various parts of India. Huge amount of info readily available on all topics around the world through google search;
Comment-
Blackstrap molasses is waste product of refined cane sugar production. it comes with slightly sweet to bitter variety depending on remnant sugar. Karupatti however is from neera, the sweet sap of palmyra flower and produced at cottage level where palm trees are abundant. Neera when fermented becomes “Toddy” and when allowed to stand over extended time becomes vinegar retaining all original nutrients (in fact there is increase of nutrients)with all alcohol converting to vengar. I presume Ayurveda’s range of Arishtams are venegars containing extracts of various herbs. You can have jaggery from date palm sap (popular in W. Bengal), Palmyra palm sap,coconut palm sap apart from sugarcane juice. The constituents greatly vary from white sugar which is no where natural and is poison compared to palmyra jaggery which has half the glycemic index of white sugar apart from a lot of minerals -see comparison -http://www.sweet-tree.biz/ (extracts below);
Macro-nutrients (mg / l - ppm, dry) Coconut Palm Sugar Brown Sugar Refined, White Sugar
Nitrogen (N) 2,020 100 0
Phosphorus (P) 790 30 0.7
Potassium (K) 10,300 650 25
Calcium (Ca) 60 240 60
Magnesium (Mg) 290 70 10
Sodium (Na) 450 20 10
Chlorine (Cl) 4,700 180 100
Sulfur (S) 260 130 20
Boron (B) 6 0 0
Zinc (Zn) 21 2 1.2
Manganese (Mn) 1 2 0
Iron (Fe) 22 0.6 0.6
Copper (Cu) 2 12.6 1.2
Source: COMPARISON OF THE ELEMENTAL CONTENT OF 3 SOURCES OF EDIBLE SUGAR - Analyzed by PCA-TAL, Sept. 11, 2000. (MI Secretaria et al, 2003) in parts per million (ppm or mg/li)
Health Attributes of Palm Sugar Nutrients:
Macro-nutrients Health benefits provided by these nutrients
Nitrogen (N) help treat cardiovascular diseases
Phosphorus (P) important for bone growth, kidney functions and and cell growth
Potassium (K) reduces hypertension, helps regulate blood sugar, helps control cholesterol levels and weight
Calcium (Ca) vital for strong bone and teeth, and for muscle growth
Magnesium (Mg) essential for metabolism, nerves and stimulates the brain (memory)
Sodium (Na) plays a key role in the functioning of nerves and muscles
Chlorine (Cl) corrects the pressure of body fluids and balance the nervous system
Sulfur (S) important for healthy hair, skin and nails, also helps maintain oxygen balance for proper brain function.
Boron (B) essential for healthy bone and joint function, enhances body’s ability to absorb calcium and magnesium
Zinc (Zn) called the “nutrient of intelligence” is necessary for mental development
Manganese (Mn) has antioxidant, free-radical-fighting properties, is important for proper food digestion and for normal bone structure
Iron (Fe) vital for the quality of blood, mental development and the immune system
Copper (Cu) helps to release energy, helps in melanin production in the skin, helps in the production of red blood cells and aid in the absorption and transport of iron.
(Back to top)
All the above benefits are available only when you source jaggery which has been least processed even if it contains sand or vegetable waste. If you allow any one to process it as a commecial product the benefts will be lost both due to so called industrial processes and greed of profit. of late i have come across articles praising benefits of consuming vegetables and fruites with minimal cleaning to take advantage the benefits of nutrients in root systems and in the skin. of course the vegetables and fruites are organically grown and donot contain high toxic loads of inorganic fertilizers, insecticides etc. In fact jaggery is regularly given to workers in under ground mines or where airborn particle pollution is high and one has opinion on a few grains of sand. it is this attitude the indudtry and trade has exploited with active support of pharma companies and medical production to implant a false sense of cleanliness and purity. It is time people should boycot all processed and packed food items including milk, sugar, flour, milled & polished cereals pulses and consume fresh locally produced vegetables and fruits.
Comment by V.Krishnan — September 30, 2009 @ 10:17 am
I produce jaggery and have been strugging to clean impurities as much as possible.Particularly soil particles and crushed cane peaces.At least this re-assues me that my product is of quality
Comment by Robbesther Wasike — December 17, 2009 @ 3:59 pm